:O
I never thought I'd be writing something DEFENDING Frank >.>;; I'm definitely not his biggest fan xD I think he was a great writer but he bought his own press, and is now just wrapped up in his own fame and anger, and he doesn't even rly bother to edit himself in his work nemore, rather just believing that everything he does is brilliant. :|
That's just how I feel about his recent stuff XD
However, something I've been reading a lot of lately is that Frank's NEVER written a strong female character before, and that they're all sexpots and stuff...
Altho it's true that he's written a lot of those types of women, and that definitely, he doesn't seem to like women a lot, ppl seem to forget about Carrie Kelley and Ellen Yindel. :O
Those were 2 strong female characters in The Dark Knight Returns, and both showed their strength playing off of the ultimate male hero, Batman :O
It can be argued that Yindel ultimately yielded to Batman and Carrie was subordinate to him, but then again, Batman beat up Superman in the book, and it's all about how Batman is awesome and right and stuff XD
Also Yindel wasn't shown as being incompetent or nething. She was capable, and altho she went after Batman, she also did the right thing (listening to Batman and saving the Governor instead of pursuing him). :)
Carrie proves that a girl becoming Robin on her own accord and not listening to Batman's orders does NOT mean that she's not "rly Robin" or that she's lost Batman's respect :O
Not only did she just become Robin without Batman even knowing who she was, but she disobeyed Batman's orders and reprogrammed his helicopter to save him :O When she asked if she was fired, he said she wasn't :)
I guess this is the Frank Miller that I wonder what happened to :|
Nowadays, Dark Knight Returns gets all the credit for bringing in the dark and gritty Batman, to bringing in the jerk Batman, for bringing darkness to comics, etc...
But I LOVE DKR, and I read it all the time, and it's not cuz it's dark and brooding and angry. :| It IS angry, but it's not TOTALLY angry, it's not this unfiltered insane angry that Frank seems to have now and that came out in The Dark Knight Strikes Again where he seems to be lashing out for the sake of lashing out. o_o
What rly resonates with me is that Batman is actually portrayed as a compassionate, good individual who inspires people. :O
Altho he was merciless with thugs, he wouldn't kill them. He had faith in Harvey Dent to reform, and even until the very end when he apprehended Harvey, he wanted to believe that it wasn't him, that he hadn't become Two-Face again. :)
My favourite part of the book is shortly after Batman made his return and the media reports about "copy cat" attacks and ppl who wear Batman costumes and shoot ppl. :|
And then at the bottom of the page is a few panels showing this regular guy, a storekeeper who doesn't like what he reads in the paper about Batman, but when he sees a woman being robbed, instead of running, he stops the crook. :O But as Frank Miller's narration notes, it doesn't make the news b/c nobody was injured.
But I rly liked the message about unsung heroes, and that Batman inspires ppl to be heroes, even if they dun agree with his methods, they agree with his message, that only people can help other people. :)
I liked how much he cared about Robin and how important she was to him. :) I liked how he was willing to give the Mutants and Sons of Batman a chance to help the city. I liked how he refused to use guns. :D
These are the things I never hear about DKR, and these are the things that Frank Miller seems to forget in All-Star Batman and Robin, like all he reads is the reviews of how great DKR is b/c it's angry and dark, and he forgets the nuance he put in the book :\
He's almost becoming a parody of himself :( And sometimes that happens to ppl when they get rly famous, they start believing their own press and they start just focussing on the stuff they're famous for, forgetting that when they first started out, they didn't have an audience to cater to, they just wrote. :|
Also, since I have the TPB of DKR, it includes the "original script" for the last chapter :\ And originally it has Batman being a real jerk and doing underhanded things to fight Superman and using guns and the people under his charge were rly violent and killing people :(
And it makes me wonder if Frank was better off when he wasn't super famous and editors actually reined him back when he got too angry or too crazy. :O
I dunno...
I know this got kind of off track... I guess, I just wanted to point out that once upon a time, Frank could write strong female characters, and that altho he hasn't written many, he wrote at least 2 in DKR. :)
Also, it gave me a chance to say what I liked about DKR :) To me, it's a story about hope and about how there is good in humanity and sometimes we just need somebody to remind us that it's in ourselves :D